Patient Education Materials Assessment Tool: How to Use It
The score is a reason to look again, not a grade.

A handout cabinet in a busy clinic can hold dozens of sheets. Some were written in house, some came from a drug company, and no one is sure which ones patients can use.
The Patient Education Materials Assessment Tool, or PEMAT, gives a clinic a structured way to look. For printed materials, a reviewer answers 24 agree or disagree items. Seventeen measure understandability and seven measure actionability. Each scale is scored as the share of applicable items the handout meets. Two reviewers who agree in advance on the few ambiguous items can score a handout in one sitting.
What the PEMAT measures
The tool was developed for the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. The printable version, the PEMAT-P (opens in a new tab), asks two questions of a handout.
Can a patient understand it? The 17 understandability items cover content, word choice, numbers, organization, layout and visual aids. Does the handout make its purpose evident? Does it use common, everyday language and the active voice? Are medical terms defined when used? Is it broken into short sections with informative headers?
Can a patient act on it? The seven actionability items ask whether the handout names at least one action the reader can take and speaks to the reader directly. They also ask whether it breaks each action into explicit steps and offers a tangible tool, such as a checklist, where one would help.
The two scales are scored separately for a reason. A handout can be clear and still leave the reader with nothing to do. Our article on writing handouts describes the study behind that: actionability scores tracked how well consumers did with a material, and understandability scores did not.
How to score a handout, step by step
The form sets out seven steps. In practice they come down to a few rules.
Rate from the patient's chair. The form asks the reviewer to "consider each item from a patient perspective" and to base ratings "ONLY on what is in the material". A clinician who already knows the subject will fill gaps the patient cannot.
Agree only when the handout nearly always meets the item. The threshold is "nearly all of the time (80% to 100%)". The guiding rule is strict: if there are obvious places where the handout could have met an item, or met it better, rate it disagree.
Use not applicable only where the form offers it. Some items allow it, such as numbers when there are none, or headers for a very short handout of two paragraphs or fewer. Every other item gets a 1 or a 0.
Score each scale as a percentage. Add the points, divide by the number of items rated, leaving out the not applicable ones, and multiply by 100. The form's example: 12 agree, 3 disagree and 1 not applicable is 12 out of 15, or 80 percent.
The form sets no pass mark. It says only that a higher score means a more understandable or actionable material. A reviewer who rates many materials "may get a sense" of what scores are exceptionally good or poor.
The items reviewers disagree on
When the tool was developed, four rounds of testing (opens in a new tab) with untrained raters ended in moderate agreement by one measure and strong agreement by another. A later study had two raters score each of 110 materials (opens in a new tab). Agreement was high overall, with a median of 0.92 for understandability and 0.93 for actionability. But it varied by item, and the weak spots are worth knowing before a clinic starts.
Numbers (item 6). This item had the lowest agreement. The form excludes times and dates, and raters split on whether phone numbers and addresses count.
Summary (item 11). Raters disagreed here too. When the study team checked, none of the materials had a summary at all.
Medical terms (item 4). Some raters argued that a handout must use certain medical terms so patients can talk with their clinicians, and that defined terms should not be penalized.
Visual aids "whenever they could" help (items 15 and 26). Raters found the wording too subjective.
The fix is a short conversation before scoring. Decide how the team will rate those four, write it down, and use the same rule for every handout.
Most of these raters were health professionals, and the materials had been written by trained health educators with a style guide. A clinic's own cabinet may score lower.
What a PEMAT score can and cannot show
There is some evidence that the scores mean something to patients. In a validation of the Japanese version (opens in a new tab), about 800 lay adults saw materials that had scored high and about 800 saw materials that had scored low. The first group rated their materials as easier to understand and to act on, and their confidence in doing the recommended action rose more.
Those were the readers' own ratings, in translation. They were not tests of comprehension or of what patients did afterward.
The PEMAT also measures something reading level does not. In the 110 material study, PEMAT scores and reading grade moved in opposite directions, but the relationship was weak and not statistically significant. The authors called the PEMAT "a useful supplement to reading level alone".
The score is a reason to look again, not a grade. It finds the handout that names no action or hides the main point on page two. It cannot say whether a particular patient understood.
A PEMAT routine for one afternoon
Pick three handouts the clinic gives out every week. Instructions for starting metformin or a home plan for plantar fasciitis are typical. The most used handouts matter most.
Agree on the four ambiguous items first. Then have two people score each handout separately.
Compare scores item by item. Where the two disagree, read that part of the handout together.
Fix the actionability items first. Name one action near the top, break it into steps, and add a checklist or a blank the clinician fills in.
Rescore, then test with a patient. Ask a patient or two what they would do first, the question the four pillars of better patient education also asks. That step is the one no score replaces.
A handout earns its place in the cabinet when a patient can use it at home.
Let's Complete the Care.


